Are Ethereum tokens a security?

Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors

It is really not for the SEC to determine whether tokens are security; this is to be determined by legislation or for the courts to determine. To date no court has determined whether or not tokens are deemed to be securities. That said it is clear that the SEC has interpreted the matter and are finding tokens to be securities. There is a case currently ongoing in New York which may however become the first court in the world to rule on whether or not tokens are deemed to be securities.

There was a lot of talk about an SEC meeting of late which was rumoured to be regarding whether Ethereum was to be deemed a security. However it appears to have been nothing more than just rumour.  Instead it appears to be the case that two subcommittees instead sat to discuss how blockchain technology can be used. The hearing concluded that the technology has a wide variety of applications but a lack of industrywide standards currently. 

There was nothing mentioned in relation to Ethereum and whether it could be deemed a security. That said however, the SEC chairman Jay Clayton is previously deemed to have stated that ethereum is not a security. 

Furthermore on an analysis of Ethereum using the Howey Test which looks at 4 factors:

1.Whether there is an investment of money

2. Whether there is a common enterprise.

3. Whether investors have reasonable expectation of profit

4. Whether profits derive from managerial efforts of others

it is clear that Ethereum does not fall into the Howey definition of a security.

It should be added that it is really not for the SEC to determine whether tokens are security; this is to be determined by legislation or for the courts to determine. To date no court has determined whether or not tokens are deemed to be securities. That said it is clear that the SEC has interpreted the matter and are finding tokens to be securities.

There is a case currently ongoing in New York which may however become the first court in the world to rule on whether or not tokens are deemed to be securities.

It is a criminal matter concerning an ICO for a real estate coin called REcoin. The case claims there was fraud through  misstatement as no tokens were actually given to investors.

One argument proffered by the defence is that currencies are explicitly not included in the definition of securities under the 1933 and 1934 Acts and in fact the 1934 Act expressly excludes currency from the definition.  

In relation to this specific coin, the defence also argues that it was to act as a currency as this coin was to allow real estate parties including purchasers, lawyers tenants etc to purchase the coin to facilitiate real estate transactions and therefore acted as a unit of account as part of the smart contract. As such it is a currency and explicitly excluded as a security under the Act  .

A constitutional argument has also been put forward considering currencies are explicitly excluded, thus making the statue contradictory as it applies in this case because many courts have said cryptos are currencies.

Again it shows the attempt to regulate this asset class using the framework of the 1930s is causing further trouble for the States. Certainly the arguments proffered above by the defence in this case are arguable however it remains to be seen how the court will determine the tokens. For now, the simple but unsatisfactory answer is that whether a token is a security depends on the full analysis of the particular type of Cryptocurrency product concerned but there is no reason to accept that tokens are automatically a security . We expect this will eventually be dealt with by Supreme Court judgment or by a new law from Congress.

All news
Trusted Solicitors in Dublin

If you're searching for a solicitor in Dublin you can trust, Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors offers expert legal services with a reputation for delivering clear advice, strong representation, and client-focused results. Based in the heart of Dublin, our firm provides high-quality legal services across a wide range of areas for individuals and businesses alike.

Text Link
CASP Registrations Ireland – Expert Legal Support for Virtual Asset Service Providers

Are you a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP) in Ireland? Navigating the CASP registration process with the Central Bank of Ireland can be complex. Our specialist solicitors are here to simplify the process and ensure your business is fully compliant.

Text Link
Property Solicitor Ireland – Trusted Legal Expertise with Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors

Are you buying or selling property in Ireland? Whether you're a first-time buyer, a seasoned investor, or navigating a complex property dispute, Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors offers the trusted legal guidance you need. As a top-rated property solicitor in Ireland, we provide comprehensive and client-focused property law services tailored to your needs.

Text Link
Trusted Solicitor in Dublin – Expert Legal Services for Every Need

Looking for a reliable solicitor in Dublin? Whether you're facing a legal dispute, buying a property, or need professional advice, having an experienced Dublin-based solicitor on your side is essential. At Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors, we offer comprehensive legal services tailored to individuals, families, and businesses across Ireland’s capital.

Text Link
Buying Property in Ireland in 2025: What You Need to Know - 10 Step guide to buying a property in Ireland

Purchasing property in Ireland remains a significant milestone, whether you're a first-time buyer, upgrading your home, or investing in real estate. As we progress through 2025, understanding the current landscape is crucial to navigating the process effectively.

Text Link
How to Apply for Recognition of a Foreign Divorce in Ireland 2025

How to Apply for Recognition of a Foreign Divorce in Ireland. If you have obtained a divorce outside of Ireland and are now living in Ireland, it is crucial to ensure your foreign divorce is legally recognised. Without official recognition, your marital status in Ireland may remain "married" in the eyes of Irish law, potentially affecting remarriage, inheritance rights, and even immigration applications.In this article, we outline the process of applying for recognition of a foreign divorce in Ireland, explain the legal criteria, and offer practical tips to help you avoid delays.

Text Link