School choice dispute | Family law

Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors

The recent High Court case of BB v AA which was an appeal from the Circuit Court deals with a situation where parents cannot agree on the choice of school for a child.

School choice dispute

The recent High Court case of BB v AA which was an appeal from the Circuit Court deals with a situation where parents cannot agree on the choice of school for a child.

The applicant (“Mr. B.”) and respondent (“Ms.A.”) are husband and wife who have now separated and are living apart. They have two children, one of which  is aged twelve years of age and is just about to enter secondary school.

The dispute was appealed to the High Court from the circuit court over  the choice of school for the young boy, in the course of judicial separation proceedings, pending in the Circuit Court.

The boy is talented and aptitude tests show that he is ranked in the very highestpercentile of scholastic achievements for a child of his. He was offered a place in what the court called School A (for ease of reference) which the court held was a good school with a high level of academic and other achievements.  However the child was also offered a place in School B has an outstanding reputation and is, the court held , by common consent, one of the leading schools in the country. Unlike School A, School B is, however, a private school and the school fees are considerable.

Mr. B. wished for his son to attend School A. His argument was that it is a perfectly good school and that such are the precarious state of the family finances that the family cannot afford private education. He also made the point that on attending School B, his son would automatically be associating with children from wealthier backgrounds which may make him feel isolated.

Ms. A wants her son to have the  best opportunity and does not want to pass up this opportunity. School B offered a discount of 50% after  the Circuit  Court ruled that the boy should attend  School A.  Ms. A.’s parents have also offered to pay the balance of the school fees.

The court held that it could resolve matters of this kind under the  of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 (as amended) which provides that any guardian “may apply to the court for its direction on any question affecting the welfare of the child and the court may make such order as it thinks proper.”

The court pointed out that its decision did not endorse School B at the expense of School A, still less to suggest that private education is in some way more desirable than education in the public system but in considering what is best for the child , given especially his scholastic aptitude it seemed appropriate that he should go to a school that would seem best suited for his talents .

The court therefore held that the appeal be allowed and Ms A was allowed to enrol the child in School B however did mention that should the financial assistance regarding fees not materialise the position would have to be revisited.

All news
Want to Start a Fintech Company in Ireland? Fintech and the law

Check out our new video on setting up a fintech company in Ireland! Do you know what fintech laws you need to abide by? Need a fintech solicitor? Our video has all the fintech answers you need.

Text Link
EU cryptocurrency regulations 2022 update

Crypto regulations Ireland and the EU - update. The law around cryptocurrency may change again, with a set of compromises to the original MiCA legislation announced by the European Union on the 28th of February 2022.

Text Link
Recent case - Norwich Pharmacal Order obtained against Coinbase Europe Limited by Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors

Cosgrove Gaynard Solicitors were delighted to be involved in a recent case for a private client in the High Court, in which we sought a Norwich Pharmacal Order to direct Coinbase Europe Limited to hand over details of an account/account holder who may be connected with stolen bitcoin.

Text Link
Awards - Fintech Law firm of the Year in Ireland 2022

Awards: Fintech Law firm of the year in Ireland 2022

Text Link
Need a Property Solicitor?

If you’re buying or selling a property, changing mortgages, or investing, it's going to be absolutely vital that you have the services of an expert property solicitor in your corner.

Text Link